Top 3 Best Dog Treats for Training: Expert Guide to Choosing the Right Rewards

The best dog treats for training are small, soft, and irresistible to your dog, making them perfect for quick rewards during training sessions. These treats should be easy to chew, low in calories, and exciting enough to keep your dog focused and motivated throughout the entire training process.

Finding the right training treats can transform your sessions from frustrating to rewarding. Whether you're working on basic commands or advanced skills, the treats you choose play a massive role in how quickly your dog learns and how engaged they stay during practice.

In this guide, we'll break down what makes a great training treat, compare different options, and help you find the perfect rewards for your dog's training journey.

Stock up on quality rewards for your training sessions. Browse our dog food and treats collection for nutritious options.

What Makes a Good Training Treat

Effective training treats need specific qualities that maintain your dog's focus and motivation without disrupting training flow.

Size and Texture

Training treats should be pea-sized so dogs can swallow them quickly without extensive chewing. Soft treats work better than crunchy biscuits because dogs eat them in seconds and immediately refocus. 

The texture should allow easy breaking into smaller pieces, letting you adjust portions based on your dog's size and task difficulty.

Smell and Taste

Strong-smelling treats made with real meat, cheese, or fish grab your dog's attention even in distracting environments. Higher-value treats should be reserved for challenging training situations or new behaviors, while less exciting options work for known commands. 

Natural ingredients without artificial flavors create better results since dogs taste the difference and show more enthusiasm for quality options.

Calorie Content and Health

Low-calorie treats prevent weight gain during frequent training sessions. Choose options with simple, recognizable ingredients while avoiding fillers like corn, wheat, and soy that add empty calories and may cause digestive issues. 

Single-ingredient treats like freeze-dried meat or liver are excellent choices, they're protein-packed, minimal in calories, and highly appealing to most dogs.

Top 3 Best Dog Treats for Training from Optimal K9 Wellness

Finding quality training treats that deliver real results makes all the difference in your training success. Here are three exceptional options that cover different training needs and reward levels.

1. Redbarn Air Dried Beef Training Treats

Redbarn Air Dried Beef Training Treats are specifically designed for training sessions and represent the ideal option for frequent rewards. This serve as one of the best dog treats for training, combining the perfect size, texture, and palatability that professional trainers look for.

The air-drying process preserves the natural beef flavor while creating a soft, easy-to-chew texture. Your dog can consume these quickly and get right back to learning without extended chewing breaks.

These treats are small enough to give repeatedly without overfeeding, making them perfect for teaching new behaviors or practicing commands that require many repetitions. The real beef ingredients ensure high protein content with minimal fillers.

Use these as your go-to training treat for everyday sessions, basic obedience work, and situations where you need reliable, consistent rewards that keep your dog motivated.

2. Redbarn Bully Twists Dog Chews

Redbarn Bully Twists Dog Chews (1.65 oz) work exceptionally well as higher-value rewards for more challenging training scenarios. While not traditional bite-sized training treats, these chews can be broken into smaller pieces or given as jackpot rewards.

The intense flavor and chewy texture make these an exciting upgrade from standard training treats. Use them when working through distractions, teaching difficult behaviors, or rewarding major breakthroughs in training.

These chews provide longer-lasting engagement than quick-consumption treats, making them ideal for marking significant accomplishments. Break them into smaller sections for multiple high-value rewards throughout a challenging session.

Reserve these for special training moments when you need maximum motivation or want to celebrate your dog mastering a particularly tough skill.

3. Redbarn Meaty Bone - Large (100% Beef Bone)

Redbarn Meaty Bone - Large (100% Beef Bone) serves as the ultimate reward after successful training sessions. This longer-lasting chew provides satisfying reinforcement that extends beyond the training period itself.

Give this bone as a "jackpot" reward after an especially productive training session or when your dog achieves a major milestone. The extended chewing time makes it feel like a special prize your dog has earned through hard work.

The 100% beef composition ensures your dog gets natural nutrition along with mental stimulation. The lasting nature of this chew also helps create positive associations with training as a whole.

Use this as a post-training ritual to wind down after intense focus work, giving your dog a chance to relax while enjoying the fruits of their efforts.

Types of Training Treats and Their Benefits

Different training situations require different treats. Understanding your options helps you choose the right reward for each scenario.

Soft Training Treats

Soft, chewy treats are ideal for most training sessions. They're easy to eat quickly, simple to break into tiny pieces, and have strong smells dogs love. These treats typically come in small cubes or strips containing real meat as the first ingredient, chicken, beef, or salmon varieties work well. 

Your dog spends less time chewing and more time learning. The downside is messiness; using a treat pouch keeps them contained and accessible.

Freeze-Dried and Dehydrated Options

Freeze-dried treats offer intense flavor in a lightweight package. The process preserves natural taste and nutrients while removing moisture, creating extremely rewarding products. They break easily into smaller pieces without leaving residue on your hands or pockets. 

Liver, chicken, and beef are popular options, their concentrated flavor makes them perfect for high-value rewards during difficult training tasks. Store in airtight containers to maintain freshness.

Homemade Training Treats

Making your own treats provides complete ingredient control and customization for your dog's preferences. Simple recipes using lean meat, sweet potato, or peanut butter are easy and affordable. 

They're especially useful for dogs with allergies. The main challenge is storage, most need refrigeration and should be used within days, though freezing works for longer storage.

Keep your dog's teeth healthy between training sessions. Check out our dog dental treats for daily oral care.

Popular Training Treat Options

Not all training treats perform equally in every situation. The table below highlights key features of different treat types to help you match the right option with your training needs.

When to Use Different Treat Types

Match your treat choice to the training environment and difficulty level. In your home with few distractions, regular training kibble or basic soft treats work fine. Your dog doesn't need ultra-high-value rewards for simple tasks in familiar settings.

Outside or in public spaces with distractions, upgrade to freeze-dried meat or cheese. The stronger smell and taste help keep your dog's attention on you instead of the environment.

For teaching new behaviors, use your dog's absolute favorite treats. Save these special rewards exclusively for challenging training moments so they maintain their high value.

Rotate treat types to prevent your dog from getting bored. Dogs appreciate variety just like we do, and mixing up rewards keeps training sessions exciting.

How to Choose the Best Training Treats for Your Dog

Every dog has unique preferences and dietary needs. Finding the best training treats means considering several specific factors.

Consider Your Dog's Size and Appetite

Small dogs need tiny treats to avoid overfeeding, a pea-sized piece might be too large for a Chihuahua but perfect for a Labrador. Adjust portions based on your dog's weight and daily calorie needs. 

For large dogs, use slightly bigger pieces that still allow quick consumption. If your dog isn't food-motivated, experiment with different flavors and textures until you find what excites them.

Account for Allergies and Sensitivities

Dogs with food allergies need treats from safe protein sources. Limited ingredient treats with one or two components are ideal for sensitive stomachs and easier to digest. Always introduce new treats gradually, giving small amounts first and watching for digestive upset or allergic reactions.

Factor in Your Training Goals

Basic obedience training allows moderately appealing treats since you're working in controlled environments. Behavior modification or training around distractions requires higher-value, irresistible rewards, especially for leash reactivity, recall challenges, or fear-based behaviors where motivation is critical.

Check out our guide on how to stop dog from pulling on leash for tips on using treats effectively during leash training.

Competition or advanced training benefits from variety in treats. Using different rewards helps maintain your dog's enthusiasm even during long training sessions or repetitive drills.

Top Characteristics of Effective Training Treats

Professional trainers and veterinarians agree on certain qualities that make training treats exceptionally effective. Understanding these characteristics helps you evaluate any treat option you're considering.

Features That Drive Results

The most effective training treats share common attributes that make them powerful training tools:

• Instant appeal: The smell alone should make your dog excited and focused on you.
• Quick consumption: No extended chewing or breaking required, just a fast reward.
• Appropriate size: Small enough to give frequently without causing weight gain.
• Consistent quality: Each piece should be similar in size and taste for predictable results.
• Portable packaging: Easy to carry in pockets or pouches without making a mess.
• Nutritious ingredients: Real food that contributes to your dog's health rather than empty calories.

Look for products that combine these features into a convenient, effective training reward system.

Common Training Treat Mistakes to Avoid

Even experienced dog owners sometimes make mistakes with training treats that undermine their effectiveness. Avoiding these common errors improves your training outcomes.

Using Treats That Are Too Large

Big treats slow down training because your dog spends time chewing instead of learning. They also add excessive calories and fill up your dog too quickly, reducing motivation for continued training.

Break larger treats into smaller pieces before training sessions. This simple preparation step keeps your session moving smoothly and your dog focused.

Inconsistent Treat Quality

Using wildly different treat values randomly confuses your dog about what behaviors are most important. Save your best treats for the hardest tasks and use consistent rewards for known behaviors.

Don't downgrade treat quality too quickly when teaching new behaviors. Keep rewards high until the behavior is solid, then gradually transition to lower-value options.

Poor Storage Practices

Stale treats lose their appeal and effectiveness. Store soft treats in airtight containers and keep them refrigerated if needed. Freeze-dried options need protection from moisture to maintain their crunch and smell.

Treats that smell bad or look moldy should be discarded immediately. Using spoiled treats risks making your dog sick and can create negative associations with training.

For dogs needing extra nutritional support, consider our guide on fiber supplements for dogs to maintain digestive health during training.

Key Takeaways on Selecting the Best Dog Treats for Training 

Choosing the right training treats transforms your sessions from challenging to successful. Start by finding treats that are small, soft, and irresistible to your dog. Build a rotation of different value levels to match rewards to training difficulty while monitoring ingredients and calories for optimal health.

Remember, the perfect training treat works seamlessly with your style and your dog's preferences. Experiment until you find what makes their eyes light up, that enthusiasm drives effective training and strengthens your bond.

Training should be enjoyable for both of you. With the right treats and these strategies, you're set for success. Ready to find premium training treats your dog will love? Explore our collection at Optimal K9 Wellness and discover options designed to make every training session rewarding.

Related Reads You Might Enjoy

If you found this guide helpful, you might also like:

• Best Dog Training Collar: How to Choose the Right One for Your Pet
• What Is a Tactical Dog Collar and When to Use It
• How to Train a Dog With a Shock Collar Safely & Effectively

Frequently Asked Questions About Training Treats

What do professional dog trainers use for treats?

Professional trainers typically use small, soft treats made from real meat like chicken, beef, or liver. Freeze-dried options are extremely popular because they're lightweight, mess-free, and highly motivating. 

Many pros carry multiple treat types with different value levels to match the training situation and maintain the dog's interest throughout sessions.

What are the best training treats for dogs?

The best training treats for dogs are small enough to eat in one bite, soft in texture for quick consumption, and made with high-quality protein as the first ingredient. 

Look for treats that are low in calories since you'll give many during training. The ideal treat should be something your specific dog finds irresistible but doesn't cause digestive upset.

Do vets recommend specific training treats?

Veterinarians generally recommend treats with simple, natural ingredients and without artificial preservatives, colors, or flavors. Single-ingredient freeze-dried meat treats often get approval because they're nutritious and have minimal additives. 

Vets emphasize that training treats should make up no more than 10% of your dog's daily caloric intake to prevent weight gain.

What treats motivate dogs the most?

High-protein treats made from real meat typically motivate dogs most effectively. Freeze-dried liver, chicken, and beef rank among the top choices because of their intense smell and taste. 

Cheese and hot dogs also work as powerful motivators, though they should be used sparingly due to higher fat content. The most motivating treat varies by individual dog.

How often should you give treats during training?

Give treats immediately after every correct response when teaching new behaviors. As your dog learns, gradually reduce frequency to intermittent reinforcement where treats come unpredictably. 

For well-established behaviors, you can reward every few repetitions or replace some food rewards with praise and play to prevent treat dependence while maintaining motivation.